SA vs. SA2

[HCMissile]

i loved sonic adventure! SA2 had major props but SA just took the cake for me. i loved the would environment and the story was fun(SA2 as well) but SA's story was im many ways much more vivid and deep. the whole 6 character thing was really cool, with only the exception of big(sonic players like to run fast, not fish) and i prefered the big mouths from SA rather than the emensly small mouths from SA2. tails in SA was much cooler in SA than SA2, and i liked tikal a lot, its to bad she was only a spirt, otherwise knux could have gotten a major GF! and everyone loved chaos! the god of distruction. robotnik also didnt call himself eggman at the time like in SA2 where he rants "I AM DOCTOR EGGMAN!" what moron calls himself his own insult, not even robuttnik is that stupid!... well.... ok he is, but i still like robotnik rather than eggman as his real name. sonic and the gang can still call him that if they want, but you know, dont push it. i loved all of robotniks bosses in SA much better than the SA2 bosses. most of the SA2 bosses were so dumb! especially the big boom boo ghost (what the heck?!)

if they ever made an SA3, i would prefer to see much more stuff from SA than SA2

SA2 however had graphics and general storyline over SA. i mean common! shadow! that is like the coolest character since knuckles! and the robots in SA2 were simply much cooler than most likely any sonic game robots as a whole ever! the whole ark space station, and the eclipse cannon, ultimate lifeforms, gerald and maria robotniks storys, vivid emotional expresions, vivid game worlds, it was a really great game!

my vote still goes to SA however. other opinions?

[Sonic Yoda]

It's very difficult to chose a favourite from both games because they're both brilliant in their own way. But I do like the fact that Sonic Adventure has the adventure fields and Sonic Adventure 2 hasen't. I always liked the way you could just wander around Sonic's world without having to do anything.